Tuesday 17 April 2012

Intellectual Property – the solid foundation for investable businesses


What is Intellectual Property?
Intellectual Property (IP) is a bit of a mine field. As a term, it encompasses a wide range of rights recognised by various laws in various geographies covering legal copyright, trademarks and patents among others. As a concept, it is hotly disputed as to whether it contributes positively to innovation or restricts it. As a legal framework, it is so varied on an international basis that trade disputes and legal challenges are the bread and butter of an army of lawyers.  As a practical tool for protecting the ideas of inventors, it is complex and can often seem confusing, but it remains the best method we have today for protecting the rights of the inventor or author to their creations.

Patent assertion
The importance of securing the rights of a business to its IP can be seen in the plethora of law suits active around the globe. Whether it is Apple and Motorola in Germany or Oracle and Google in the USA, ‘patent assertion’ is the order of the day. And the value of these patents is on the increase, too. Microsoft is reported to be planning to buy patents from AOL for more than $1 billion. There are even companies in existence today whose sole function is to hoover up the patents of other businesses with a view to selling them on for profit.

The wind-up radio
It is not just technology giants who are concerned about the security of their IP. For a small business looking to create new solutions to old problems, ‘the idea’ itself is often the starting point. 

I recently attended a talk by Trevor Baylis, the inventor of the wind-up radio and a strong advocate for teaching Intellectual Property within the national curriculum in schools. When he heard that the spread of AIDS in Africa could be combated by the improved education of people if only they had access to radios which, because of the lack of electricity and the cost of batteries, were not available, he decided to solve the problem. 

He had the idea of producing a wind-up radio that would be cheap enough for widespread use in Africa. Trevor is an engineer and used his domain knowledge to build prototypes and prove his design. The next thing he did was to patent his idea. In his talk, he said that the greatest day of his life was meeting Nelson Mandela in South Africa, part of the recognition that he got from helping to save countless lives. All possible because he secured the rights to his invention. 

The importance of the investor
However, Trevor also told of the obstacles he faced in getting recognition for his idea and the problems of making it happen. It wasn’t until some eagle-eyed investors recognised the opportunity and established the means to generate a commercial model that the wind-up radio was successful.

It often takes the genius of the original idea together with the money of savvy investors to bring innovations to market. But those investors in the wind-up radio were only interested in committing their money when they knew that the idea was protected. Not only did the patent give protection to Trevor Baylis, it also gave protection to the investors.

A solid foundation for small business success
Small businesses can learn from this example. When the product of a new company is ‘new ideas based’ and has clear market potential, it is essential that the foundations of that business are built upon the rock of Intellectual Property protection. 

Without it, it will be very difficult for that business to gain the support of the investment community. With it, alongside strong management and solid profit forecasts, the investor can take heart that the opportunity has a much higher chance of exploiting competitive advantage. 

And, as we are seeing in the recent spate of patent trading, there may be hidden value in the patent itself.

No comments:

Post a Comment